Stages of Denial: ‘Global warming is part of a natural cycle’–This idea is one short step above appealing to magic

Objection: Current warming is just part of a natural cycle.

Answer: While it is undoubtedly true that there are natural cycles and variations in global climate, those who insist that current warming is purely natural — or even mostly natural — have two challenges.

First, they need to identify the mechanism behind this alleged natural cycle. Absent a forcing of some sort, there will be no change in global energy balance. The balance is changing, so natural or otherwise, we need to find this mysterious cause.

Second, they need to come up with an explanation for why a 35% increase in the second most important greenhouse gas does not affect the global temperature. Theory predicts temperature will rise given an enhanced greenhouse effect, so how or why is it not happening?

The mainstream climate science community has provided a well-developed, internally consistent theory that accounts for the effects we are now observing. It provides explanations and makes predictions. Where is the skeptic community’s model or theory whereby CO2 does not affect the temperature? Where is the evidence of some other natural forcing, like the Milankovich cycles that controlled the ice ages (a fine historical example of a dramatic and regular climate cycle that can be read in the ice core records taken both in Greenland and in the Antarctic)?


Is this graph a candidate for explaining today’s warming? A naive reading of this cycle indicates we should be experiencing a cooling trend now — and indeed we were gradually cooling over the length of the pre-industrial Holocene, around .5C averaged over 8,000 years.

Not only is the direction of the change wrong, but compare the speed of those fluctuations to today’s changes. Leaving aside the descents into glaciation, which were much more gradual, the sudden (geologically speaking) jumps up in temperature every ~100,000 years represent a rate of change roughly ten times slower what we are currently witnessing.

So could current changes be part of a natural cycle? Well, no natural cause has been identified. There is no climatological theory in which CO2 does not drive temperature. And natural cycle precedents do not exhibit the same extreme changes we’re now witnessing.

In short: No.


This entry was posted in Eco Information, From Other Blogs, Grist. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Stages of Denial: ‘Global warming is part of a natural cycle’–This idea is one short step above appealing to magic

  1. klem says:

    Lets look at your title another way.
    Stages of Alarmism: ‘Global warming is NOT part of a natural cycle’–This idea is equally one short step above appealing to magic.

  2. Citizen Harry says:

    The only magic in your argument is that you try to make something obvious disappear with smoke and mirrors. It’s usually someone who has something to gain (money/power) from polluting the world with fossil fuels, etc. Those are the ones who argue loudest, shouting that climate change is something science has made up. (I guess because they’ve got nothing else better to do with their time). Go ahead, keep arguing that we don’t need to worry that the road we’re going down while mindlessly spewing chemicals is a dangerous one. What’s your reason to shout it down? Or are you just a “My Fox News” kind of ‘believe everything the right wing tells me’ kind of guy… huh, Klementine?

    Oh, I know… we need those fuels. Just like we needed abestos in our plaster…or lead in our paint. Yeah, I know.

  3. Hubert says:

    To prevent the greenhouse from getting too hot and killing the plants, windows or vents can be opened to release the excess heat, thus
    maintaining perfect growing temperatures inside. Well, then,
    how would they do this without causing a real-life Armageddon.

    We cannot use technology to refreeze disappearing glaciers or the ice caps, refill rivers,
    remake their entire ecology or stop rising oceans due to global warming.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s